This week on The Temporary: Juan Escalante and Gabe Ortiz on fixing America’s immigration system


As immigration continues to be a “scorching button” difficulty that Republicans exploit to rile up their base, what’s at stake for brand new migrants arriving for the border, and the way can we assist undocumented immigrants already dwelling in America? How can we assist undocumented Individuals, in addition to make sure the inhumanity of the way in which migrant kids are being handled on the border? Ortiz and Escalante mentioned the trail ahead.

A lot of the progress we now have seen to date was constructed on the years of labor put in by immigration reform advocates. As Eleveld famous, an excellent deal modified after activists pushed President Obama to signal the DREAM Act into legislation: “The DREAM activists modified the norm, they modified the paradigm. They modified it in order that it’s exhausting to return to ‘regular.’” Eleveld questioned what the GOP might supply as a substitute, as they appear so centered on complaining about this that in all conversations in regards to the difficulty, they are obfuscating the truth that the state of affairs on the border nonetheless requires a humane resolution.

Senators like Ted Cruz exemplify this lack of care about discovering actual options, as he and his colleagues proceed to make jokes in regards to the dire state of the American immigration system and make use of more and more hard-line, anti-immigrant rhetoric towards the migrants. As Escalante defined,

As a substitute of making an attempt to truly making an attempt to determine a manner ahead … [Republicans like Ted Cruz] would quite simply attempt to basically poke enjoyable at it and proceed to feed the beast that’s the far proper, and to be trustworthy … the Republican Occasion as an entire, even when they got here up with an answer, it wouldn’t be an answer that is grounded in actuality … it’s grounded within the rhetoric of Steven Miller and Donald Trump to attempt to shift the dialog that manner.

Whatever the conduct of GOP members of Congress, the group agreed that each one eyes are on the present administration, which has lots of potential to extend protections for undocumented immigrants. However, as Escalante stated, “What the Biden administration is doing is making an attempt to basically roll the DACA program right into a rule-making course of whereas it’s navigating the authorized system, the judiciary, proper now.” He emphasised:

Congress has the authority proper now to basically move payments and ship one to the President to make sure he fulfills his promise of bringing as many individuals out of the shadows … There’s some political will on the market, however sadly, what we’re seeing is actually excuses from some Republican members of Congress. We’re seeing relics of the previous, just like the filibuster, stand in the way in which. I feel that if we’re going to go daring and really rework this nation into a greater place for all, then we have to do that proper now and never watch for midterms or every other elections to come back round. We’d like decisive [action] proper now.

By way of concrete motion, Escalante additionally famous that a lot of payments are making their manner by way of Congress proper now, together with the U.S. Citizenship Act of 2021, laws to supply citizenship to migrant farmworkers, the Dream and Promise Act, and the DREAM Act.

Moulitsas and Escalante then mentioned the pushback on immigration reform and assist for hardline anti-immigrant insurance policies amongst sure elements of the Latino neighborhood within the U.S., urging the necessity for nuance when discussing the cultural views on the problem and never assuming a monolithic opinion.

There’s an pressing want to fight the unfold of misinformation amongst immigrant communities, Ortiz and Escalante stated, by exhibiting that Biden is delivering on the protections their communities want—and never Republicans. In addition they urged listeners to know that denying help to kids mustn’t even be a degree of debate. Ortiz added,

There’s an urgency there as a result of they’re kids. They are already actually susceptible once they come to our nation, and much more so as a result of they’re coming with out a guardian. They is likely to be coming with a sibling, or maybe an older relative, however as a result of it’s with out a guardian, they’re already lacking somebody who can be an advocate for them in regular circumstances. There’s an urgency as a result of there are such a lot of kids caught in these border services. There are basic agreements that these services usually are not match for kids, however the hazard is that there are various kids who’re caught in these services as a result of they can’t be transferred to HHS rapidly sufficient.

It’s clear that change is required—however how can we get entangled? Escalante urged folks to name members of Congress to ensure they assist payments and amendments that construct a pathway to citizenship for hundreds of thousands of individuals, together with important frontline employees like healthcare employees, grocery retailer staff, migrant farmworkers, and extra. Ortiz additionally believes a elementary shift away from oppressive techniques can also be essential to making sure justice for migrants:

We actually need to strain our legislators and President Biden to maneuver away from the coverage of throwing billions at ICE, and CBP, and the wall, and as an alternative use that cash to create a greater, extra humane system the place we deal with kids with dignity and humanity—the way in which we’d need our personal kids to be handled.

Moulitsas closed the present on a sober word, addressing the hypocrisy of the Republican Occasion and its insurance policies and using kids as a speaking level or cudgel for the social gathering platform when helpful. As he stated, “You don’t shut the door on folks in want. And for Republicans to speak about abortion and saving kids and the infants, however then be so viciously anti-helping kids after they’re born—so many examples, from help to single moms to this—actually exhibits how merciless they’re … It’s by no means been about kids.”

This week’s episode may be considered under:

Thanks for tuning right this moment! The Temporary now additionally obtainable on the next podcast streaming platforms: