San Francisco tech firms are sitting on file quantities of empty area and providing perks to lure tenants


Individuals put on protecting face masks exterior Salesforce Tower in New York Metropolis.

Noam Galai | Getty Pictures

Cloudera exited its downtown San Francisco workplace early final 12 months with plans to sublease the area and transfer its staff south to the software program firm’s Silicon Valley headquarters.

However the pandemic left the corporate with no person to take over the workplace, forcing it to take a considerable actual property write down.

At DoorDash’s close by former headquarters, a tenant defaulted on lease a month into lockdown, leading to misplaced revenue for the meals supply firm, which was doubling as a landlord.

Airbnb stated in its earnings report on Thursday that it took a $113 million impairment within the first quarter “associated to workplace area in San Francisco that we deemed not obligatory.”

Mixed, these three firms have recorded almost $200 million in actual property impairments previously 12 months after Covid-19 turned the Bay Space workplace market right into a useless zone. That greenback determine swells to virtually $1 billion when including in lease-related write downs from giant tech employers Salesforce, Dropbox, Uber, PayPal, and Zendesk.

Whereas software program and web firms continued their stratospheric ascent in 2020, the plush places of work they name residence sat dormant, leaving San Francisco’s business actual property market with an unfamiliar provide glut. A lot of the monetary fallout was borne by the very tech firms that led a decade-plus bull market and enlargement spree, snapping up huge quantities of area at file costs and infrequently subleasing out full flooring to start-ups and out-of-town companies that have been searching for a Bay Space outpost.

By the top of the primary quarter of 2021, the quantity of vacant sublease area in San Francisco had soared to 9.7 million sq. toes, up from about 3 million in late 2019, and accounted for 40% of all out there business area within the metropolis, in keeping with business actual property agency Avison Young.

Mark Cote, co-founder of T3 Advisors, a tech-focused actual property agency that helps tenants with their development plans, stated that firms in search of an workplace in San Francisco have a uncommon alternative over the subsequent two to 3 quarters to get in at a reduction. In contrast to conventional landlords, which have been reluctant to drop lease costs, tech firms with extra area are typically keen to supply cut-rate rents and take the loss as a result of they’ve already “confronted the counting on the impairment,” Cote stated.

“There is a worth window for tenants in San Francisco earlier than the boomerang impact, the place folks and corporations are going to come back again,” stated Cote, whose agency operates in Boston, New York and the Bay Space. “For those who’re a sublandlord, you soar on an lively tenant.”

Cote stated firms paying $90 a sq. foot could provide subleases for $20 to $25 much less and eat the distinction. Robert Sammons, senior director of Northern California analysis at actual property agency Cushman & Wakefield, stated that along with these reductions, firms are “layering on incentives akin to free lease and extra tenant enchancment allowances.”

Skyrocketing vacancies

Even with the reductions, it is nonetheless not simple to seek out takers.

The Bay Space has been sluggish to reopen, and downtown San Francisco stays pretty hole, at the same time as vaccination rates within the metropolis are among the many highest within the nation and Covid cases have plunged. Tech firms have stayed productive with staff working from residence, assuaging the strain to deliver them again to the workplace and main many to begin planning for a hybrid future with much less want for actual property.

The general workplace emptiness price in San Francisco climbed to 18.7% within the first quarter from 6% a 12 months earlier, Cushman & Wakefield reported in its market overview for the interval. That is the very best since 2005, when the town was nonetheless recovering from the dot-com collapse. Numbers are equally inflated in main markets like New York and Chicago, however these cities are much less reliant on tech, the trade that is gravitating most aggressively to distant work.

Previous to the pandemic, analytics firm Cloudera had deliberate to maneuver a number of hundred staff from its San Francisco and Palo Alto, California, places of work into its headquarters simply south in Santa Clara. When the shutdowns started, the transfer was underway however the firm hadn’t but discovered any alternative tenants, leaving the area empty.

With no person to pay the lease, Cloudera needed to take an impairment charge final 12 months of $35.8 million. Mick Hollison, Cloudera’s president, stated in an interview that the Palo Alto workplace “would have been anyone’s envy only a few brief years in the past and now it’s totally tough to sublease.”

Hollison stated he expects about half of Cloudera’s staff to return to the workplace in some capability this 12 months, but it surely’s seemingly that about 25% might be completely distant and plenty of others will solely are available for a part of the week.

“Our footprint will shrink over time,” he stated.

Elsewhere in San Francisco, DoorDash took an $11 million impairment within the first three quarters of 2020. The app-based meal supply firm stated in its IPO prospectus {that a} tenant’s enterprise was disrupted by the coronavirus and it instructed DoorDash in April “that it will not be making any future month-to-month lease fee.”

Airbnb’s $113 million cost within the first quarter of 2021 provides to $35.8 million in lease impairments last year. The room-sharing firm laid off about 25% of its staff a 12 months in the past because the journey market cratered.

After Uber slashed about 20% of its workforce early within the pandemic, the ride-hailing firm, which had been quickly increasing in San Francisco, discovered itself with approach an excessive amount of actual property. Uber stated in its 2020 annual report that it “exited, and made out there for sublease, sure leased places of work, primarily because of the Metropolis of San Francisco’s prolonged shelter-in-place orders and our restructuring actions.” The corporate recorded lease-related impairments for the 12 months of $94 million.

Signal on facade at jobsite for development of latest headquarters of Uber Inc asserting work stoppage and delays throughout an outbreak of the COVID-19 coronavirus in San Francisco, California, March 19, 2020.

Smith Assortment | Getty Pictures

Uber had 824,000 sq. toes of accessible sublease area throughout 4 areas in San Francisco on the finish of the primary quarter, in keeping with Cushman & Wakefield, by far probably the most of any firm. Dropbox was second with 418,000 sq. toes, after the collaboration software program firm introduced plans to go remote-first. Dropbox’s impairment last year was simply shy of $400 million, adopted by a further $17.3 million charge within the first quarter.

Salesforce, San Francisco’s largest personal employer, has 287,000 sq. toes out there. The corporate took $216 in impairments final 12 months because of “actual property leases in choose areas we have now determined to exit,” in keeping with the corporate’s annual report.

‘Beginning to see them re-enter’

Nonetheless, Sammons stated, exercise is selecting up. Tenant demand is on the highest since earlier than the pandemic started, indicating that extra firms are looking for area. Sammons stated {that a} direct lease (by way of a landlord) of 200,000 sq. toes is about to be introduced, which would be the largest for the reason that pre-Covid days.

“Some had pulled out and placed on pause any type of expansions, and we’re beginning to see them re-enter the market,” Sammons stated.

There’s additionally been current motion in subleases. Design software program firm Figma just took over 100,000 sq. toes of downtown area from Credit score Karma, which moved its headquarters to Oakland. And Dropbox has been discovering takers for giant chunks of its vacant area.

BridgeBio, a drug developer, just lately took close to 53,000 square feet from Dropbox, and Vir Biotechnology, one other life sciences firm, agreed late last year to sublease about 134,000 sq. toes of the complicated.

Vir’s worth per sq. foot begins at $47.77 this 12 months and rises 3% yearly to $68.11 in 2032, in keeping with the lease agreement. When Dropbox signed its original 15-year lease in 2017, the corporate agreed to pay $62 per sq. foot in 12 months one, climbing to $93.78 within the remaining 12 months. In leasing 736,000 sq. toes at that worth, Dropbox was then reportedly signing the biggest workplace deal ever in San Francisco.

Whereas Dropbox could should depend on reductions and different perks to lure potential tenants, the corporate is in a novel place to draw biotech corporations. Its complicated is in an space referred to as Mission Bay that is stuffed with medical facilities and is zoned for all times sciences firms.

Demand for area is so excessive within the booming biotech trade that earlier this 12 months personal fairness agency KKR purchased the property for about $1.1 billion, with Dropbox nonetheless answerable for the rest of its lease.

“Life sciences firms at the moment are trying on the metropolis as a result of they see this chance,” Sammons stated. The Dropbox constructing “has the ground plates and the ground plans, and all the pieces is constructed and prepared for all times sciences firms.”

The sudden shift to what Dropbox is asking its “Digital First” mannequin has turned a cloud software program firm that was on the forefront of San Francisco’s emergence as a tech hub into one of many metropolis’s greatest sublandlords. At its slimmed down headquarters and at different areas throughout the globe, Dropbox is sustaining some area for in-person collaboration and workforce gathering classes.

Dropbox stated in its newest quarterly report that whereas it expects to generate extra sublease revenue and avoid wasting cash by going distant, “there isn’t any assure that we are going to understand any anticipated advantages to our enterprise.”

Different San Francisco-based tech firms like Twitter, Square and Okta have instructed staff they’ll work from wherever now and into the long run.

Nonetheless, T3’s Cote expects San Francisco to bounce again even when 20% or so of jobs are completely distant. Tech employers should be extra versatile and rational with their bodily area, however they nonetheless need to be within the heart of the motion, he stated.

“The primary factor everybody has to recollect is the expertise of the labor power,” Cote stated. “You may’t replicate that in a single day.”

— CNBC’s Jordan Novet contributed to this report

WATCH: Cushman & Wakefield’s CEO on why he’s confident office demand will return